Hrrm, I really do believe that this thing should get at least flamethrower and fire blast, every rock type does that doesn't have a secondary type that totally coincides with fire :S
So you're saying rock, ground, fire, and ghost hit 31 OUs SE? Even if Rockmon doesn't get Flamethrower, he still might get shadow ball so the coverage is still there if you use HP fire. Are you against Shadow Ball also?I will jump on the "no flamethrower" bandwagon here.
Some meanlingness numbers: The combination of fire-ground-rock hit around 25 OU pokes SE (x2 or x4). To have a parameter, Electivire (which is the OU example of type coverage) hit 29 of them SE with 4 moves on its standard set. This means that with the proper hidden power (and a possible 90 BP attached with Technician), Rockmon can actually surpass Electivire. For example, if you include Hidden Power Ghost, you will hit around 31 OU pokes SE, which is a really nice number. Also, unlike Electivire, who needs motor drive to activate in other to "sweep", rockmon can sweep right away with its 130 base speed AND it actually resists physical hits better (and special as well if you include sandstorm). This may not seem much, snce Electrivire is decreasing in usage, but with only with 3 moves, it has the potential to surpass the offensive power of said poke (if you consider the speed, better defenses and the abilties), giving you an extra slot to add whatever you want, possibly improving even more its power.
I am probably playing too much theorymon here, but I find the idea of having a poke with 3 moves being able to deal damage like an other OU poke with 4 moves scary. I'd much rather keep fire as hidden power, so you will have to give up some coverage to give it a fire attack, and maybe a more effective ability to have a powerful attack.
I'd not mind Thunderbolt and Ice Beam and *insert grass move*, TBH, but flamethrower/fire blast/overheat....ehh....it is kinda risky. But that is me.
Alakazam has paper defenses, is pursuit bait, and has a type immune to its attacks. Rockmon has none of those disadvantages, and in fact, in addition to being immune to Sandstorm, gets an SDef boost. The two are nothing alike, including the fact Zam is still slower than at least one of its counters, Weavile.This post made me smile a bit.
Admittedly for this very reason I'm against a +2 boosting move like NP. I think that Calm Mind may or may not be acceptable. Notably Alakazam has CM and has 135 SA, 120 Speed. Mind you, as you've noted, he doesn't have a very good movepool. However that doesn't actually balance it out, he's BL and not used very often at all. I think that if this is Alakazam-esque with a good movepool it may very well be OU without going overboard.
One important thing to remember is that Garchomp, the best example of a just-over-the-line Pokemon we can compare this to, doesn't just have no counters: it has no counters with ONE SET. Like I said before, if there's too much use of the word "or" in your arguments about Rockmon, it becomes increasingly unrealistic because there's only 4 moves per set. I also believe that most people are going to have priorities, so some moves will simply be more useful in general than others. For example, Azelf usually doesn't run Thunderbolt or Shadow Ball. Deoxys-E doesn't often run Grass Knot or HP Fire. Gengar doesn't usually run Psychic or Energy Ball.
I know it's very possible for this to be broken if we're utterly careless, but I'm really shocked at how trigger-happy some of us are with using the word "broken", a main reason perhaps being that we recently banned Garchomp, and this is troubling. I remember how we all thought that Charge Beam would be broken on Pyroak and, as it turns out, he's a fairly average Pokemon. I don't know about any of you, but I don't want Rockmon to be an "average" Pokemon.
Well, I should hope that CAP 5 would have some advantages over Zam, or else he would be borderline...Alakazam has paper defenses, is pursuit bait, and has a type immune to its attacks. Rockmon has none of those disadvantages, and in fact, in addition to being immune to Sandstorm, gets an SDef boost. The two are nothing alike, including the fact Zam is still slower than at least one of its counters, Weavile.
You are missing two important pointsOriginally Posted by Fat Frosty
I will jump on the "no flamethrower" bandwagon here.
Some meanlingness numbers: The combination of fire-ground-rock hit around 25 OU pokes SE (x2 or x4). To have a parameter, Electivire (which is the OU example of type coverage) hit 29 of them SE with 4 moves on its standard set. This means that with the proper hidden power (and a possible 90 BP attached with Technician), Rockmon can actually surpass Electivire. For example, if you include Hidden Power Ghost, you will hit around 31 OU pokes SE, which is a really nice number. Also, unlike Electivire, who needs motor drive to activate in other to "sweep", rockmon can sweep right away with its 130 base speed AND it actually resists physical hits better (and special as well if you include sandstorm). This may not seem much, snce Electrivire is decreasing in usage, but with only with 3 moves, it has the potential to surpass the offensive power of said poke (if you consider the speed, better defenses and the abilties), giving you an extra slot to add whatever you want, possibly improving even more its power.
I am probably playing too much theorymon here, but I find the idea of having a poke with 3 moves being able to deal damage like an other OU poke with 4 moves scary. I'd much rather keep fire as hidden power, so you will have to give up some coverage to give it a fire attack, and maybe a more effective ability to have a powerful attack.
I'd not mind Thunderbolt and Ice Beam and *insert grass move*, TBH, but flamethrower/fire blast/overheat....ehh....it is kinda risky. But that is me.
Rockmon does have paper physical defenses. The rest of the points are taken, however I don't think those are breaking Rockmon with a good movepool, considering that Alakazam is so uncommon because of its problems. If anything, I think that these little bonuses will help Rockmon surpass Alakazam rather than break him.Alakazam has paper defenses, is pursuit bait, and has a type immune to its attacks. Rockmon has none of those disadvantages, and in fact, in addition to being immune to Sandstorm, gets an SDef boost. The two are nothing alike, including the fact Zam is still slower than at least one of its counters, Weavile.
90/65 Defense is much better than Lucario. Does Lucario have "paper defense(s)?" No. It isn't a tank, but it doesn't die from a random non-SE STAB hit. For Comparison, Gar has 60/60 and Alakazam has 55/45.Rockmon does have paper physical defenses. The rest of the points are taken, however I don't think those are breaking Rockmon with a good movepool, considering that Alakazam is so uncommon because of its problems. If anything, I think that these little bonuses will help Rockmon surpass Alakazam rather than break him.
I also think it's a stretch to say that the two are nothing alike. They're both fast special sweepers, and I have doubts as to whether or not Rockmon will be using boosts.
Typing means much more than pure stats, especially when it comes to switch-ins. Lucario has 3 4X resistance and an immunity, so every move named Megahorn, Stone edge, Crunch, Bug Buzz, Dark Pulse and Toxic to name a few are safe swtich ins. Same can be said for Gengar, with all the Earthquakes, Toxic, Grass Knot and assorted Normal attacks thrown around. What does have our Rockmon? Normal attacks, which are not so common. Fire moves, ok. Flying moves, which are not so good switch-ins, since many flying attacks barring Togekiss ones are physical - to put in perspective, Choice Band Adamant Staraptor's Brave Bird does 69,77-82,31% to no HP/Def EV CAP5. And, ah yes, Poison. The worst attacking type in the game. Only useful to be immune to in order to avoid Toxic, but a resistance... who cares, really?90/65 Defense is much better than Lucario. Does Lucario have "paper defense(s)?" No. It isn't a tank, but it doesn't die from a random non-SE STAB hit. For Comparison, Gar has 60/60 and Alakazam has 55/45.
Alakazam has as much in common with Rockmon as it does with Zapdos. Being a special attacker that can sweep is the only thing they have remotely in common. Everything else from type matchup to weather effects to counters is completely different. I think Porygon-Z has a very slight edge on this defensively.
This has 95 Physical tankiness and 102 Special tankiness, PZ has 99 and 104.
Zam has 57 and 93, Gar has 74 and 88, Lucario has 89s.
Obviously this surpasses Zam, Zam lost a lot of things in the shuffle to DP it would have preferred to keep, and a large portion of its safe switchins moved around, to Zam's detriment. In fact, in X-Act's analysis tool this has "average" defenses, whereas most of the rest of them fell into Below Average or Bad in some cases.
Alakazam always has its variety hour of cool tricks in Trick, Encore, Screens, T-Wave, etc. Alakazam is better at doing those sorts of things where this will be more focused into a special, and possibly, for anyone crazy enough, mixed sweeper.
Flash Blitz/Flare Dash
Type: Fire
BP: 40
Accuracy: 100%
BP: 30
Priority: +1
Damage: Special
Description: Fire version of Quick Attack.
Not only a move which annihilates most of his checks is suspect, but i dont like the idea of giving to CAP5 a new move whose type is different. There's no precedent to this.
Vital Impact/Stone Shot
Type: rock
BP: 90
Accuracy: -
BP: 20
Priority: 0
Damage: Special
Description: Rock version of Aura Sphere.
Again, i think this move is too powerful. Come on guys, if we give a move like this to CAP5, it will be used even over AP on the Tech set for matters of PP... I know we must not nerf this because of Technician, but giving it a move like this would sound like giving Recover as well as Moonlight to Revenankh, pretty much rendering the secondary ability almost useless.
Flash Blitz/Flare Dash
Type: Fire
BP: 40
Accuracy: 100%
BP: 30
Priority: +1
Damage: Special
Description: Fire version of Quick Attack.
I don't really like the names, but aside from that, I think it could work as a useful tool against Scizor who otherwise rapes Rockmon completely.
Not so worried about the 'precedent' - this is only CAP5 zarator. I'd be more worried about the potential for this to be seen as a very unproffessional move.
Vital Impact/Stone Shot
Type: rock
BP: 90
Accuracy: -
BP: 20
Priority: 0
Damage: Special
Description: Rock version of Aura Sphere.
Well zarator, everyone has been talking about a Rock version of Aura Sphere so what would you nerf in order to make this a suitable alternative to Tech AP?
I just think Alakazam just completely gotten outclassed by Azelf. With higher defense, Flamethrower, Thunderbolt, Explosion, Stealth Rock and many moves that Alakazam has, it's making Alakazam not as useful, even with its higher SPA and SPE, it's simply nowhere near good enough.Actually I don't see Alakazam as having that great of a movepool. With the transition from ADV to DPPt, it lost the elemental punches, becoming physical, and earned only Grass Knot, Shadow Ball and Focus Blast in compensation, which simply aren't as good as having a Special Electric, Ice and Fire attack. I think that is the main reason why it's not OU.