For challenge members battling eachother, make sure it is clear who is the challenger and who is the challenge member (I ought to find a new name this is going to get confusing, lol). So in the example of edgar vs dice, since Dice was battling as a challenger his win counts as such (so it doesn't add to his WL ratio) and edgar's loss is as a challenge member (so he isn't on the waiting list and it does count towards his WL ratio). In the case of a challenge member losing as a challenger, the victory wouldn't count to the other member's own challenge. (so if edgar had won he would still have to beat Dice as a challenger)