For transparency I will provide my reasoning for each of my votes for this voting slate
I think it’s very self-explanatory as to why I voted for a
ban for the reasons brought up in this thread a million times. It trades far too well and stat checks the entire tier with its bulk allowing it to 1v1 almost the entire metagame. It trades two for one at minimum with it often cleaning games entirely with nothing breaking past it as it heals itself with Drain Punch. Terastallization further compounds this issue, as using Tera Ghost or Tera Fire allows Iron Hands to destroy common answers such as Scream Tail and Skeledirge, additionally gaining a Ground neutrality vs foes like Hippowdon with Tera Ghost and getting past it. There’s just very few Pokémon that generally check it pre-tera and Iron Hands will get a lot of opportunities to come in and boost against common Pokemon like Kleavor, Hydreigon, choice-locked Arcanine, and Meowscarada to name a few in addition to a lot more. This is a very clear-cut
ban for me; Iron Hands is already absurdly powerful but its versatility in the moves and Tera types it can run allows it to get around almost every answer to it, which is just too much for me and I believe that keeping it in the tier any longer will impair its growth and development.
I voted
Do not Ban on Hydreigon. I will say that I find that Hydreigon is still very strong in the metagame, but I can’t ignore that the tier has gotten faster with new Pokémon such as Galarian Zapdos, Thundurus-T, Hisuian Lilligant, and Meowscarada being great in addition to pre-home Pokemon that Hydreigon hasn’t interacted much with like Pawmot, Greninja, and Cyclizar. Hyper offense has generally been revitalized with a lot of the new threats we’ve gotten which has the potential to overwhelm Hydreigon and is a clear contrast to the bulky playstyles Substitute + Nasty Plot preys upon. Additionally, we have some new checks to Hydreigon that aren't just offensive pressure; Hisuian Goodra and Alolan Muk check Hydreigon well with Assault Vest, forcing it into Earth Power to hurt them. Tera Water Skeledirge owns Hydreigon with Unaware ignoring the boots and Torch Song bypassing the Substitute, while Quaquaval resists the Dark Pulse + Flash Cannon combo and hurts it back, with Quaquaval still being a solid enough Pokemon even post shifts. However, it’s the sheer dominance of Iron Hands that keeps Hydreigon from being truly insane to me, losing out on the benefits of Substitute or a good attack combo in Flash Cannon + Dark Pulse for Draco Meteor or Earth Power to hurt it. Even then, Iron Hand’s bulk or a nice predicted reactive Tera will still stop Hydreigon, and the simple restriction of its move slots is a huge deterrent alone. However, as we all know, Iron Hands isn’t lasting long in the tier, and Hydreigon could very well become broken in the following week since Substitute can mess with offensive checks and could be seen as a restrictive presence. Still, I cannot see Hydreigon as broken in a metagame with Iron Hands and voted
Do not Ban as such.
The other Pokémon I voted to
ban is Hisuian Lilligant. I think the Tera Ghost set lacks reliable counterplay with the brutal coverage its STABs + Tera Blast Ghost covers, crushing foes such as Gengar, Talonflame, Galarian Slowbro, and Tornadus-T that normally check its STAB combo. Its great speed gives it a lot more setup chances with its typing than one would think against foes such as Kleavor, Hippowdon, Tyranitar, Wo-Chien, and Zarude, boosting its Physical Defense in front of something slower to limit damage taken, not to mention Tera Ghost giving it a resistance to Poison and eliminating weaknesses to types such as Fairy, Flying, and Ice helps a lot. +1 in Defense from Victory Dance is a massive help in living priority and when setting up vs a slower foe, ultimately giving Lilligant greater leeway when it misses with Hustle. Speaking of Hustle, in conjunction with Wide Lens, it doesn’t miss that often, having roughly 90% accurate moves which isn’t that bad, meaning it’s still an insane wallbreaker that doesn’t need Leftovers or Life Orb to function as Wide Lens alone helps alleviate a huge issue. Counterplay is limited to Fat Salamence, which is not good with Speed and power being needed, Fat Moltres, Enamorus-t, and reactive Tera from stuff like Quagsire and Skeledirge. Yes, Skeledirge is an amazing and very common Pokemon. And yet, it is still only one Pokemon that can check Lilligant reliably with the others not being great, relying on Tera to beat it, or having the possibility of losing to Lilligant. I do urge readers to try this Pokémon out because it is absolutely insane and something I will be voting
ban on, and should it survive this vote I will do my best to push for action in the future.
I thought this Pokémon would be dumb as shit but for now it’s balanced so I voted
Do not Ban on it. I think Tera Blast is a waste because it’s a huge commitment and even then doesn’t play out ideally with the lack of luxury to have enough turns to prime itself for a sweep. It’s also very restrictive to have your tera locked in or the Pokémon ends up kinda useless. After talking about it in council, I’ve really begun to like just dual STABs and function as a trade Pokémon that can force helpful sequences to capitalize on, plus having tera flexibility with Tera Dark for more power or Tera Steel for better defensive use like resisting Bullet Punch and Extreme Speed is extremely helpful. It still has its checks in Tera Fairy Skeledirge, AV Hisuian Goodra, AV Alolan Muk, Tyranitar, Tinkaton, and Mimikyu regardless. Overall, I’ve found Tera Blast to be a waste on Goltres from my experience as a cheese user on ladder and find dual STABs to be the better set, which is something I do not consider broken at the moment, prompting me to vote
Do not Ban.
I've had some changing views about this Pokémon since we actually have it. At first, I thought it was overrated garbage destined for RUBL, but now I think it’s balanced and a good part of the tier, at like a high A- viability level. Still, it’s definitely the most overrated Pokemon by far and I
don’t find this Pokémon banworthy at all. It has too many factors that keep it in line between a Stealth Rock weakness requiring extensive team support featuring just ok entry hazard removal, bad defensive typing in conjunction with low speed making it vulnerable to tons of faster threats, and reliance on a choice item to do damage which makes it prediction reliant and more easier to play around. Slowbro, Slowking, Alomomola, Quagsire, Hippowdon, Donphan, and Gastrodon all handle it well enough defensively to the point where the matchup is pretty outplayable. It’s just not that crazy of a Pokémon when it’s not difficult at all to take advantage of its exploitable and outplayable traits, ending up with it being still good but not broken at all. We've seen strong breakers like this before such as Pawmot and Staraptor which ended up being fine and enough to handle so I don’t see Hisuian Arcanine as any different. This is a very easy
Do not Ban vote for me.
Where do I start lol. I think this Pokémon should worry about being higher than B+ before being broken because I don’t even think it’s that good, let alone banworthy. Spore is the main scary part of it but it’s outplayable with right positioning and sacks and once that happens Breloom is left pretty vulnerable. On such a slow Pokémon, its typing doesn’t do any favors and it really needs to predict right and go out of its way to get in even to attack. Scream Tail, Salamence, Skeledirge, Talonflame, both Moltres, both Thundurus, Torn-t, Azelf, Gapdos, Gengar, Ceruledge, Glowbro, Enamorus-t, Alolan Decidueye, Mimikyu, and even more will all handle breloom well and keep it from taking over. Offensive counterplay is a very integral part of counterplay that cannot be ignored; look at Tyranitar, where with a Choice Band and Tera Dark it even overwhelms Quagsire and Hippowdon, its main switch-ins. And yet, it was still balanced due to low speed, a typing that can be exploited, and a reliance on Choice Band. My point is, Breloom is not too much different. Spore is annoying but it generally gets run over by offensive teams and it really needs to click the right move each time to make progress because otherwise it gets forced or KOed itself. And I’d argue breloom has a LOT of offensive counterplay. Another very easy
Do not Ban vote for me.
The last Pokemon under inspection is Skeledirge, who I voted
Do not Ban on. I think it’s an extremely nuanced Pokémon who is shown to be powerful because the meta is new and we aren’t optimizing our building. I get that it’s bulky and has great snowball potential and difficult to switch into but there’s notable flaws to it too. First, you are more often than not burning your tera on it which is big. I’ve also found to vortex it with not too much effort with momentum cores and it burns Slack Off a LOT in games. Switching into a Salamence or Moltres means you have to click Slack Off immediately which leaves you open to being exploited. We’re seeing a rise in Poison-types such as Gengar, Alolan Muk, Galarian Slowbro, and Grafaiai who can hit Skeledirge post-tera and all but Galarian Slowbro can hit it pre-tera in addition to mons that can muscle through it such as Thundurus-T, Tyranitar, and Basculegion-F. Other Pokémon and techs that give it trouble include Future Sight cores, Ceruledge, Hisuian Arcanine, Toxic Quagsire and general status ailments that burn Slack Off, Tera Fire Scizor and Maushold, Encore Tinkaton, Taunt Tornadus-T, and DD Taunt Gyarados and Tyranitar, not to mention the tons of Pokémon that affect it pre-tera. Still, please do not get me wrong at all; Skeledirge is a phenomenal and influential Pokémon in the metagame that is very potent and a likely S rank candidate. I just don’t see it as too overbearing to go immediately alongside Pokemon I find insanely strong like Iron Hands and Hisuan Lilligant, instead finding it more nuanced and less consistent lately to where I rate Meowscarada over it as a Pokémon. Can it be problematic down the road? It’s definitely possible. Right now, it’s something I would like to evaluate over UUWC pools before even considering tiering action. As of now, since I do not think Skeledirge is a problematic element in the metagame, I voted
Do not Ban on it.
This is the actual last one but I’ll share my stance on :Galarian Zapdos: since it’s been talked about a fair bit here. I thought it would be dumb before the drops happened but so far I have felt
it’s fine. Maybe some Bulk Up set down the road could be crazy but choice sets are fine. Choice Scarf is not bad to check but everyone knows this so I’ll talk about Choice Band. I compare it to Staraptor, who is frailer and has a Stealth Rock weakness but is ultimately stronger. Staraptor was flawed because the main move it clicked (Brave Bird) killed itself over time in addition to a weakness to Stealth Rock and the tier had enough tools to deter the beatdown from Brave Bird. Choice Band wasn’t even the best set because of its exploitable Speed, and Staraptor itself ended the pre-home metagame in C+, which is really low. Galarian Zapdos is not too different, sharing the same Speed tier as Staraptor and hitting the same Speed benchmark with its own Choice Band set that rendered Choice Band Staraptor ineffective. With Gapdos, the main move it WANTS to click is Brave Bird, as we’ve got a lot of Fighting-Type resists in the meta that deter Close Combat and makes Brave Bird the ideal click. However, Brave Bird wears down Galarian Zapdos a lot when it should be a Pokemon that is alive for a while making progress throughout the game on BO teams. In conjunction with Rocky Helmet and Stealth Rock chip, Galarian Zapdos will not be lasting as long as one would like. Base 100 Speed is also just not that fast these days, being vulnerable to a lot of fast stuff. Once again, it could be broken down the line, but comparing it to Choice Band Staraptor, who is stronger yet still got kept in line by the numerous Flying-resists and faster threats we have so far, ending up being near-unviable by the end of the pre-home metagame, means that Gapdos might not be as broken of a wallbreaker as we think. Over time we’ll see how much the bulk and Stealth Rock neutrality truly matters but for now Galarian Zapdos has felt like a balanced and honestly slightly disappointing metagame presence to me especially since I thought it would be insanely broken.