So, I had a recent realization with Total Drama: Pahkitew Island, and it's that Shawn kinda SUCKS
Now with TDPI, there tends to be two characters that are usually agreed on to be the best, Jasmine, and Shawn, and while I can definitely get behind that for Jasmine (she's my favorite character from this generation), with Shawn, I don't agree with the placement of him being this high at all, despite being one of the wackiest contestants in PI, he ends up being boring, since he's held back by his main and infamous schtick, to be fair, a great amount of characters have their main schtick being focused around something, but at least with them, they're interesting, even if their execution of their main schtick isn't the best
Shawn doesn't end up as interesting, he feels like just someone that functions within the role that he was arbitrarily assigned to by the makers of PI, rather than someone that works with the role that is applied to them, or they have a good amount of importance within the plot of PI that it doesn't become their defining characteristic, take my top two for example, Jasmine and Scarlett, Jasmine is a compelling character that just has great interactions overall, and is by far the more interesting character with the will they won't they relationship trope with Shawn, meanwhile, Scarlett is great because I get a kick out of her smartassing the competition, and her interactions with Max is FUCKING COMICAL
Those two characters work well, so how does Shawn work in the vacuum of Pahkitew Island? Well, his plot always ends up having something to do with the fact that he "sees" zombies, and gets deathly afraid of them, so he runs away, or on occasion, fights the "zombies", even though no zombies ever show up in the first place, but that doesn't stop him, it ends up making him run away from the challenges on occasion, the worst part is that he never actually changes this habit, until the very end, the plot development for him is DRY, his whole character never gets to take a break from being the guy that's paranoid of zombies
Dave is infamous for his whiny behavior in the second half of Pahkitew Island, and sure, he's most definitely annoying, but at least the writing gave him plot development, and he was allowed to deviate from his schtick of being obsessively clean, I wouldn't call the execution of his plot good, but, he was at least allowed to be interesting, Shawn meanwhile, had no plot development, and this joke was dragged on far after it overstayed its welcome, he ends up feeling like the early boots due to that they had no plot development, but at least they are early boots, Shawn meanwhile, stayed for a long time,
he even ends up being a finalist for crying out loud, he ends up lackluster, I wish there was something more interesting done with him